A survey reported that only 11% of consumers trust the first search tool they use, prompting most to validate across Google, AI, and review platforms. AI usage is rising quickly, but purchase decisions still hinge on price transparency, reviews, and clear product or service details. For home service contractors, winning requires consistent presence across Google Search/Maps/LSAs, key review sites, and AI answers. The article outlines six search personas with actionable tactics and gives practical guidance to make sites machine-readable and conversion-focused without wasting budget.

Homeowners Don’t Trust the First Result — Here’s How Contractors Win the Second Look (and the Call)

TL;DR Only 11% of U.S. consumers trust the first tool they use. Most double-check across search, AI, and reviews. AI use is surging (73% increased use; 45% daily), but purchase decisions still swing on price, reviews, and clear specs. For HVAC, plumbing, and electrical, this means you need consistent presence across Google Search/Maps/LSAs, review sites, and AI answers — and pages built to earn calls, not clicks.

What the Data Says — and Why It Matters for Trades

A new survey (Researchscape for Yext) found only 11% of consumers trust the first search tool they use. Translation: most people validate. They start on Google (45%), then bounce to AI tools (15%), review sites (14%), and social for proof (52% for reviews; 48% for local recs). AI is now daily for 45% of people, but when it’s time to buy, old-school drivers win: price, peer reviews, and product specs.

If you run a home services business, assume every job-winning journey is multi-touch. A homeowner might see your LSA, skim your site, ask AI for “best plumber near me on a Sunday,” then read your Google reviews. You don’t need to “win AI.” You need to be the contractor who looks solid no matter where they check.

The Six Search Personas — How to Capture Each

The survey outlines six personas. Here’s the practical translation for contractors:

• The Traditionalist (24%): Lives in Google Search/Maps. Tactics: dominate your service area with LSAs, strong GBP, and exact-match search campaigns for symptom + service + city (e.g., “no heat repair Denver”).
• The Price Shopper (21%): Wants deals and speed. Tactics: show upfront ranges, diagnostic fee, financing, coupons in ad assets and landing pages. Use price extensions and callout extensions.
• The Explorer (18%): Uses AI for deep dives. Tactics: publish clear FAQs and service pages with structured data so AI pulls your answers. Add “when to repair vs replace,” “SEER2 explained,” and “emergency checklist.”
• The Creator (15%): Idea-oriented (you’ll see them on social). Tactics: short how-to videos, before/after photo galleries, and “what to expect” posts. Repurpose into YouTube Shorts/Reels.
• The Social Proof Seeker (14%): Trusts reviews and influencers. Tactics: push review velocity after every job, highlight review snippets in ad copy, and pin top reviews on landing pages.
• The Accidental Searcher (8%): Finds you scrolling social. Tactics: geo-targeted social ads with emergency hooks and click-to-call; show real tech photos and vans.

Be Everywhere They Validate — Without Wasting Budget

• Google Business Profile (GBP): Fill every field (services, service area, hours, after-hours, photos, products). Post weekly. Answer Q&A. Keep NAP consistent everywhere.
• Local Services Ads (LSA): Verified, background-checked, review-rich profiles win. Dispute junk leads. Set aggressive hours for emergency categories.
• Search Ads: Separate campaigns for emergency vs. maintenance. Use call extensions, location extensions, and structured snippets (financing, warranties, same-day).
• Review Sites + Social: Focus on Google first, then Yelp/Nextdoor/Facebook where your market actually uses them. Automate review requests after close-out.
• AI-Ready Content: Add FAQs, service specs, and comparison content. Write like you talk. Mark it up with schema so machines can quote you accurately.

Make Your Site Machine-Readable and Conversion-Ready

• Structured data: LocalBusiness, Service, FAQ, and Review schema. List services with clear names (e.g., “Water Heater Replacement,” “Panel Upgrade”).
• Trust signals above the fold: Phone number, “Call Now” CTA, same-day badge, financing, license/insurance, and review count with average rating.
• Pricing clarity: Ranges and diagnostic fee. Pair with “what’s included” bullets.
•